What if Edward IV never survived the Battle of Barnet. What would life have been like had George, Duke of Clarence betrayed his brother to become King George I of England? Would he have succeeded or still faced the same fate?
The Battle
of Barnet looked to be a Yorkist victory. Edward IV’s army had its enemies
trapped in the mud. They could pick them off one-by-one. Richard Neville, Earl
of Warwick had tried, but failed to bring an end to the Wars of the Roses. But
he wasn’t going down without a fight and he would have to be killed to give up
this battle.
He thought
that would happen, until the unthinkable took place. Just as Edward IV came
towards him, he stopped; a look of shock in his eyes. Suddenly blood dripped from
his mouth and he landed hard on his knees. Warwick looked up in awe to see
George, Duke of Clarence standing above his own brother, his own sword stuck
into Edward’s back.
George, Duke of Clarence Changes Warwick’s Fate
George had
always been a tricky man to trust. He would switch sides whenever it suited him
for power. While initially unwilling to kill his brother, that changed today.
Warwick wasn’t sure why it changed right now, but it didn’t matter.
The actions
of George meant that Edward’s army had no leader. Well they did, but that new
leader had just usurped the old one. And that new leader was now clearly on the
side of the Lancastrians.
Or was he?
George
looked straight at Warwick, glee in his eyes. This was all part of a game; part
of a plot. George just wanted his older brother out of the way. The battle was
still on and Warwick realised that he wasn’t going to make it out alive.
Yet, somehow
he did. He just made it out maimed. George had decided to capture the
Lancastrians that still lived and pulled them from the mud. Many of them were
executed, but Warwick was spared. It just so happened that Warwick was George’s
father-in-law and George didn’t want to leave his wife without a father. He
knew how that felt.
Instead,
George cut off Warwick’s sword hand. It was excruciating, but Warwick was able
to remain alive.
The Battle of Tewkesbury Still Takes Place
Over the
next two weeks, Warwick was pulled in to give George some council. No, it wasn’t
council, but news of Henry VI’s army. Warwick wasn’t just going to give that
answer away. He wanted reassurances from George first.
It was
Isabel, his elder daughter, who was able to give him some reassurances. Warwick
would be
welcomed back to Court as the king’s advisor and would be made a duke.
After all, there were positions available since Edward IV’s downfall and now
death. On top of that, his elder daughter would be queen and her children with
George would be heirs to the throne.
Unlike Anne,
Isabel had already proven fertile. She lost the baby, but she could at least
bear children. Anne was still to conceive with her husband. And it wasn’t like
Henry VI or his son were really fit to rule. George wasn’t the most stable, but
Warwick could help ensure the safety for England, ruling behind the scenes
through Isabel.
Yes, he
decided to help and that gave George a major advantage when it came to the
Battle of Tewkesbury on May 4, 1471. Henry VI’s Lancastrian forces were no
match. Everyone died, including the king’s son Edward of Westminster. Only the
women, Margaret of Anjou and Anne Neville, lived but they were taken straight
to the Tower of London to be put on trial for treason.
Henry VI was
also captured and taken to the Tower of London.
The Execution of Royalty
George knew
that he couldn’t execute Margaret of Anjou without bringing about a war with
France. He wasn’t ready to do that, so arrange a ransom for her with the French
instead. King Louis XI agreed a handsome sum for his niece and also agreed to
the return of some of the lost lands due to Margaret and Henry’s wedding
contract.
Warwick was
impressed with George’s actions. He never expected this from the wildfire that
was now George I of England. However, he was more interested in the action
taken against his younger daughter, Anne.
George had
wanted to execute her as a traitor. Isabel pleaded with her husband to keep
Anne alive, even placing her under house arrest, but George refused. George
knew that once Warwick died, Isabel and Anne would get his land and
inheritance. He didn’t want Anne to get any of it, so for Anne’s trial put
together a range of men who would have a reason to find the young former
Princess of Wales guilty of treason.
Richard,
Duke of Gloucester attempted to save Anne from her execution, but was caught by
guards. George had his own brother locked away, before swiftly taking Anne’s
head and life.
Dealing with His Sister-in-Law
While all
this happened, Elizabeth Woodville remained living in sanctuary with her
children. George learned that Elizabeth had given birth to a son while in
sanctuary. Those who supported Edward’s
claim to the throne would now have
someone to place as a figurehead. He may have just been an infant now, but it
wouldn’t take long for him to be a viable contender for the throne. Elizabeth
and Anthony Woodville would make sure Edward Plantagenet would become King
Edward V one day.
George
needed to do something. He needed to remove Edward and the rest of the
Woodvilles as a threat, but he couldn’t breach sanctuary. Nobody would ever
forgive him if he did that. He would have to lure her out somehow instead.
But before
he could do that, he heard news that his wife was pregnant. George excitedly
awaited the birth of the prince. After all, if Elizabeth Woodville had finally
given birth to a boy, his wife as Queen of England would too. Unfortunately,
Isabel gave birth to a girl. This one was quickly named Margaret but George
wasn’t happy. He needed an heir to his throne. Edward IV had one and Henry VI
had one, so he needed an heir too.
The problem
now was the Lancastrians rising again. They had a king in the Tower of London.
Lead by the Duke of Buckingham and (as George would later find out) instructed
by Margaret Beaufort, they aimed to break Henry VI out of the Tower. The revolt
didn’t work. The soldiers were killed, the Duke of Buckingham executed, and
Margaret Beaufort placed under house arrest.
As for Henry
VI, George had him killed to avoid any more problems. Warwick, who had still
not been given the title of duke, reminded George of another man in the Tower
who would be a greater threat to his crown: his younger brother, Richard.
Richard had gained supporters around England while working with Edward IV.
While George had proven to lack loyalty, Richard had not.
George knew
that his brother was a bigger threat to his safety than his sister-in-law,
nieces, and nephew currently in sanctuary, but wouldn’t do anything yet. He
could execute his wife’s sister, but not his own brother. Especially not when
he had nothing that he could use against Richard that would warrant death.
The Death of a Queen
Isabel soon found
herself with child again. This time the child was a son, named Richard after
his father. Bonfires were lit around England, as an heir was born. George was ecstatic,
and pushed for Isabel to be rechurched as soon as possible so they could make
another heir.
It wouldn’t
be good for Isabel’s body. While she quickly became pregnant again, her body
hadn’t fully recovered. She was weak from the last pregnancy and gave birth to
a weak baby boy, who would be called George. Isabel struggled to recover and
was consumed by childbed fever. Just months after the birth of her second son,
she died of childbed fever just before Christmas of 1476. Baby George followed
on New Year’s Day.
The country
mourned for the loss of their queen and prince. George took the deaths extremely
hard.
Believing
them to be witchcraft, George turned to the only source he could believe would
want to see Isabel and the baby dead: Elizabeth Woodville. She had to be
conspiring to put her own son on the throne. First it would be Isabel and the
new baby, since they were already weak, and then it would be Richard, Margaret,
and finally himself.
Without
Isabel by his side, Warwick saw that George was losing all sense of control.
England had something to worry about when George stormed into Sanctuary to
retrieve Elizabeth Woodville and her children. When George and Warwick reached
sanctuary, they realised that something wasn’t right.
Everyone had
disappeared. Somehow Elizabeth and her children had fled the country. Nobody
could tell them when or how. On further inspection around the country, all the
Woodvilles had fled. It would be months later that they would hear of the
Woodvilles in exile with Margaret of York, Edward’s sister. She refused to
allow who she viewed as the rightful heirs to the throne die at the hands of
her mad brother.
George was
furious. In retaliation, he had his own brother Richard executed in secret.
Legend has it that Richard was drowned in a barrel of Malmsey wine, a way that
George had said he would always like to go. Margaret Beaufort was also
executed, as George didn’t trust her while her son Henry Tudor was in France.
The Death of King George I of England
George didn’t
last long after the events of February 1478. England turned against him, as his
mental health deteriorated. Warwick had to handle more of the king’s affairs,
and worked to put a council in place (with him as Lord Protector, of course)
for George’s young son Richard to take the throne.
In February
1483, George died suddenly. Nobody knows the real causes, but it meant that
8-year-old Richard was now King Richard III of England. The country hoped that
he would be as strong has his Uncle Edward, but that wasn’t possible with
Warwick controlling everything behind the scenes.
In Europe,
the Woodvilles realised that this was the time to attack. They’d spent the last
decade recruiting an army and were working with Jasper and Henry Tudor. On August
22, 1485, the Woodville and Tudor army headed to Bosworth Field, against Warwick’s
forces. Evenly matched and nothing to lose, Anthony Woodville and Henry Tudor
overpowered Warwick and his men, usurping the throne.
The
14-year-old Edward Plantagenet was now able to make his way to England safely
and take his place as the rightful King of England. Henry Tudor married
Elizabeth of York, a promise Elizabeth had made to Jasper in return for his men
and smarts. While Henry wouldn’t become king, he would have a place close to
the throne. It wasn’t exactly what his father wanted, but it was enough for
him, for now.
The young
Richard III of England was placed in the Tower of London temporarily. Elizabeth
wouldn’t allow her son to act in the same way as George had by executing his
own kin. Instead, Elizabeth worked with Margaret of York to have Richard raised
with her. He actually didn’t mind, especially when he heard the stories of his
father’s actions.
The
Plantagenet line continued for another four generations.
What Really Happened on April 14, 1471
George, Duke
of Clarence never did betray his brother on the battlefield. Edward IV’s men
were able to overpower Warwick’s, killing the Earl of Warwick on the
battlefield. At the Battle of Tewskesbury, Richard of Westminster was killed,
but Anne Neville’s life was spared. She would go on to marry Richard, Duke of
Gloucester.
Elizabeth
Woodville would return to Edward IV’s side as his consort and they would have six
more children after Prince Edward. George would go on to betray his brother
again and did falsely accuse a woman of witchcraft after the death of his wife.
After George’s actions, Edward IV felt he had no choice but to execute his brother, and legend says it was in a barrel of Malmsey wine.
The Battle
of Tewkesbury would be the last Wars of the Roses battle for more than a
decade. Edward IV would remain in power until his death on April 9, 1483.